Is Any Place Safe?
Three years ago Advent was shattered by the massacre of first graders and teachers in Newtown, Connecticut. An elementary school. Reactions were swift. Some called for reasonable gun restrictions, or at least a conversation. Others , for whatever reason, went out and purchased weapons and ammunition.
This summer, the country was stunned by the racially-motivated shooting of a pastor and group of parishoners at a Bible study in South Carolina. A church. Reactions were swift. Some condemned racism. Others criticized the church for not having armed guards.
Last week, Advent was once again shattered by a mass shooting at a community center in California, by jihadists committed to hate. A community center. And the week before, we were shocked by a shooting rampage at a Planned Parenthood clinic in Colorado. A health clinic.
This weekend, I joined about 40 other people, including faith leaders from several traditions, at a vigil for peace. We began at Central Christian Church, processed to the Mental Health Center, where we prayed, and then to Planned Parenthood, where we prayed and read the names of those killed in the California and Colorado rampages. It was a vigil for peace, a vigil against violence.
There is no quick fix to the problem of violence. But as Christians, we commit ourselves to pray, and to work to prevent violence. We are not all of one mind, even in the church. But there is no better place than the church to have constructive conversations on difficult topics with people who may have a different point of view. Christianity is about reconciliation, and we can model it in our conversations, having the hard conversations about the things that underlie violence. It is a gift we can give to the world, the world that God so loves.
Three years ago the Conference of Bishops responded to the multiple mass shootings that reached a horrendous climax at Newtown.
The letter from the Bishops is relevant today:
A Pastoral Letter on Violence adopted by the ELCA Conference of Bishops,
March 4, 2013
“A voice is heard in Ramah, weeping and great mourning, Rachel weeping for her children and refusing to be comforted, because they are no more.”Jeremiah 31.15 and Matthew 2: 18
Dear brothers and sisters in Christ:
Every faithful caregiver who sits with victims of violence knows what we know – as God's church, we are called to reduce violence and should, in most cases, restrain ourselves from using violence. Whether or not statistics show that overall violence has declined in recent years, every person wounded or killed is a precious child of God.
As bishops of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, we lament the tragedy of gun violence in our country. We are grieved by the way violence threatens and destroys life. We affirm the current soul searching and shared striving to find a way to a better future.
While the church grapples with this call to reduce violence and make our communities safer, we recognize that before God we are neither more righteous because we have guns nor are we more righteous when we favor significant restrictions. Brokenness and sin are not somehow outside of us. Even the best of us are capable of great evil. As people of God we begin by confessing our own brokenness – revealed in both our actions and our failure to act. We trust that God will set us free and renew us in our life's work to love our neighbors.
In this time of public attention to gun violence, local communities of faith have a unique opportunity to engage this work. As bishops, we were thankful to recognize the many resources our church has already developed (see below). We begin by listening: listening to God, to Scripture, and to each other. Providing a safe place for people to share their own stories, together we discern courses of action. Together we act. And together we return to listening - to assess the effectiveness of our efforts to reduce violence.
In the Large Catechism Luther says, “We must not kill, either by hand, heart, or word, by signs or gestures, or by aiding and abetting.” Violence begins in the human heart. Words can harm or heal. To focus only on guns is to miss the depth of our vocation. Yet, guns and access are keys to the challenges we face.
We recognize that we serve in different contexts and have different perspectives regarding what can and should be done. But as we live out our common vocations, knowing that the work will take many forms, we are committed to the work of reducing and restraining violence. This shared work is a sign of our unity in Christ.
We invite you, our sisters and brothers, to join us in this work:
• The work of lament – creating safe space for naming, praying, grieving, caring for one another, and sharing the hope in God’s promise of faithfulness
• The work of moral formation and discernment – listening to scripture, repenting, modeling conflict resolution in daily life, addressing bullying, conducting respectful conversations, and discerning constructive strategies to reduce violence
• The work of advocacy – acting to address the causes and effects of violence
Knowing that we are not saved by this work, we undertake it trusting in Christ Jesus, who laid down his life for the world and who calls us to be peacemakers, to pursue justice, and to protect the vulnerable.
In this, as in all things, Christ is with us. Thanks be to God.
• “Community Violence” a social message, http://www.elca.org/socialissues
• “The Body of Christ and Mental Illness” a social message, http://www.elca.org/socialissues
• “Hearing the Cries: Faith and Criminal Justice,” a proposed social statement
• “Peace: God’s Gift, Our Calling,” a 1995 social statement.
• “Ban of Military-Style Semi-Automatic Weapons,” 1989 social policy resolution, http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/Social-Issues/Resolutions/Search-by-Topic.aspx#guncontrol (both social policy resolutions are at address)
• “Community Violence – Gun Control,” 1993 social policy res
Jessica Crist, Bishop
Leave a Reply.
Bishop Jessica Crist
Bishop of the Montana Synod of the ELCA